5 Favorite Ice Cream Spots in Matteson, IL

One of the best parts of summer is how wonderful ice cream tastes on a hot day. This is true no matter where you live, but these five favorite ice cream spots in Matteson, IL can help you beat the heat.

Sweets Addict
The name of this eatery says it all. If you are a sweets addict, you will find your fix here. Not only is there ice cream, but also cupcakes, shakes, cheesecake, cobbler, brownies, churros, smoothies, donuts, and more. There aren’t as many ice cream flavors here as there are in ice cream-only shops, but the standard vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, cookies and cream, and butter pecan flavors are superior to what you’ll find just about anywhere else. It’s not fancy, but it’s delicious, and that’s all that matters.

Cone Cottage
Cone Cottage is a nostalgic nod to soft-serve ice cream parlors of the past. However, it does not just offer the traditional chocolate and vanilla as there are 25 flavors of soft-serve ice cream available to choose from. These colorful treats come in flavors such as tutti frutti, blue moon, pina colada, and even creme de menthe. Sundaes, banana splits, strawberry shortcake, ice cream sandwiches, frozen bananas, and more are all available to help cool you down in a most delectable way.

Plush Horse Ice Cream Shoppe
For homemade gourmet ice cream in the Matteson area, you won’t find a better spot than Plush Horse Ice Cream Shoppe. There are over 50 flavors to choose from on a daily basis, but some flavors are seasonal, and others only make a short appearance, so be sure to stock up on your favorite flavor once you decide what it is. Be aware that the portion sizes are huge and that if you only want a single scoop, order the baby scoop option because one scoop actually means three scoops. It’s a little confusing, but the servers will help you out to make sure you get all the ice cream you want.

Sugar Head
This is another shop that offers many more desserts than just ice cream, but it makes the list because its ice cream is simply scrumptious. Many visitors like to pair their ice cream with a hot and fresh funnel cake, which brings out the sweetness in both. You can even get a funnel cake sundae, which is out of this world. Try the black walnut, raspberry cheesecake, or butter pecan ice cream, or give one of the other various flavors a try.

Zarlengo’s Italian Ice & Gelato
If you’re looking for ice cream that doesn’t have as many calories as traditional American ice cream, give the Italian gelato at Zarlengo’s Italian Ice & Gelato a try. This family-owned shop offers desserts made from the freshest ingredients available and you can really tell it uses high-quality products. One of the most popular menu items is the half gelato and half Italian ice concoction because of the contrasting textures and flavors. Just be sure to bring cash as this establishment does not accept credit cards.

These five ice cream spots in Matteson are favorites by far; however, there are other places to get desserts as well. If you’re looking for something a little different than what these shops offer, stop by Sutton Ford, where a local resident can give you even more recommendations.